My favorite three in order of preference based on last night's performances:
Carly - MAN! This girl can sing! Contrary to Simon's thoughts on the song choice - I thought it was brilliant on all-counts.
David - Definitely the most-talented vocals of the "men." He needs to really shine with a non-ballad next week.
Brooke - Most talent overall. Vocally she may not be THE best...but musically - the girl gets it. She plays multiple instruments - well...and has a very clear understanding of her style, her limitations....and I like her.
And my pick for who should go home this week:
Ramiele - Cute as a button, for sure...and good pipes...but the girl just can't pick a song to save her life! Because of this, she goes home before Rocker Girl with far less vocal talent.